Hayden Medich scored twice as the Tornadoes (3-10) topped the visiting Panthers in MVL play.
Medich scored with 5:21 remaining in the first half to put West Muskingum up 1-0 at halftime and added a goal four minutes into the second half.
After a Maysville goal, Wesley King capped the scoring with a goal with 7:10 left in the game.
The Panthers outshot the Tornadoes 12-8. Blake Browning had nine saves for the Tornadoes.